NMM Progress – I’m pleased!

Anyone following the blog knows I’ve already finished the NMM on one of my SCE models (you can see him here) I picked up as an Underworlds gang. Here he is for reference:

Not bad but could be better…

The blends got better and the finish smoother from the chest plates (terrible, the first part I painted) to the knee pads and feet (much better, the last parts I painted). It’s not bad for a restart in NMM. I’m working with a limited paint pallet at the moment (partly because of the virus lockdown but mainly because I’m starting hobbying again from scratch. It’s a long story which is here if you’re interested). That’s the excuse I made for the derpy colours I used on this dude.

Enter the Komet…

But actually, after reviewing the Ben Komets Painting Buddha SCE (you can find more about him and that here) I realised that I have all of the colours I need for a much cooler (in all senses of the word) gold. I currently own the following paints:

Vallejo Model white
Vallejo Model Black
Averland Sunset (Citadel)
Balor Brown (Citadel)
Mournfang Brown (Citadel)
Rhinox Hide (Citadel)
Screaming Skull (Citadel)

To paint the bright yellow guy I used a base of Averland Sunset, a wet blend highlight of Screaming Skull and a glaze shading of Mournfang Brown. After trying a few recipes I came up with a much better base colour for the gold, a mixture of Balor Brown, Black and Mournfang Brown. I also started from a black undercoat. This is what it looked like:

Putting it all together

The next two steps were the same actually, a wet blend highlight of Screaming Skull (repeated three times to make sure it’s super smooth) then a glazed shade of Mournfang brown. However if you remember the first gold guy, the shadows were too red and there wasn’t enough contrast. So I added a further stage with this second model, a second glazed shade of Mournfang Brown mixed with Black. Once all of the steps are done on all of the gold, it looks like this:

I think it’s an improvement. Here’s a direct comparison:

I’m not saying one is better than the other here but the one on the left is definitely better! The progression, not just in the colour shoice but in the quality of the blends is really marked. I think that’s partly because I’m getting my mojo back but also partly because of colour choice making the transitions look better. Either way, I’ll take it and this is my new ‘go to,’ recipe for NMM gold.

So I’ve got one more mini left to do the NMM on and then I’m out of gold to paint and no new paints to start any other parts of the model. I’ve toyed with the ides of restarting the yellow gold dude but I won’t. I’ll keep these guys in whatever state they end up in as they represent a new beginning for me and that’s what is really important right now.

Comments and queries always welcome!

It doesn’t glitter and it doesn’t really look like gold

Lockdown has hit my new country. My new country is super small and weird anyway so everything being closed just feels like another day but it has hit. To top it all off, I’m actually feeling rough. It probably isn’t Covid-19 (there are only 15 active cases in this country, the likelihood of me being number 16 doesn’t feel weighty) but it’s enough to feel a bit run down and put myself on a status of, ‘critical meetings only,’ today and prolly for the rest of the week.

And what better way to spend self isolation than terrorising my partner and tip toeing back into miniature painting. If you’ve read my last post (it’s here) you’ll know that I’ve picked up an UnderWorlds SCE warband and some paints. The paints are just enough to do some NMM gold. Now that we’re in full lockdown it’s time to kick it all off.

Starting with the hard bit?

Why NMM? As I’ve said somewhere before; Hard training, easy racing. Easy training, hard racing. NMM is something that I find difficult (compared to basecoat, wash drybrush at least) and that’s because it is. It’s short blends, high contrast and complex light placement. I feel like if I can get back into painting via NMM then even if the result is crappy then I’ll have started the neurons firing enough that when I paint something that I really like, it’ll come good quicker than starting from square one.

Paint / brush selection

I’m not advising anyone to follow this as a painting guide or advice on colours (actually colour choice is my weakest area) but just for reference the colours I used were: Averland Sunset, Screaming Skull, Mournfang Brown all from Citadel and Black and Dead White from Vallejo Game Color. I used a wet pallet and made sure all the paints were nice and thin. There’s not much else to say about that. I used a big crappy hobby brush from Humbrol to do the base coats and then a 00 Windsor & Newton Series 7 Miniature to do the fancy nancy bits. For the next mini I’ll use a slightly bigger brush but I’m not crying about that one, I rate the brand very highly.

Let’s get started…

Anyway, all that aside, how did I go? I started terribly and got better as I went which is not what I expected. What I expected was for the whole mini to be shite to be honest but actually I ended up being pretty pleased with some of it so far.

I always start painting SCE on the breastplate. Consequently this is the weakest part of the mini:

Well first off, extreme close ups are a bit harsh at the moment! Don’t forget, this is my first painting since about August. The brush control isn’t there (the blends aren’t smooth and the highlights are too thick) and the contrast is missing (there’s plenty of highlight but the darks aren’t dark enough and the dark areas are too small.

But it got better…

I painted the shoulder pads and the back next

These are better than the breast plate. I also made a really conscious effort with the lion’s head shoulder pad to pick individual lines out to paint transitions in. Previously I tried to make a single transition across the pad as if it was flat (stupid I know). This one has come out pretty cool.

The finishing stretch

Then finally I did the legs

The close up is really harsh here too but the legs are the best part of the mini so far (from an arm’s length I’m really pretty pleased with them). Is it6 the best mini I’ve painted? Nope. Is it the best NMM I’ve painted? Nope. Is it the mini I’m most pleased with? Maybe, actually! It’s a new start, a new beginning. Once these guys are all finished, I’ll keep these as a reminder that no matter how hard it gets, just keep moving forwards.

I hope you’ve enjoyed this as much I’ve enjoyed painting him so far (you definitely haven’t by the way). I’m going to get the other two minis in the warband to this point before I venture back outside (zombie apocalypse notwithstanding) to buy a few more paints for the next part of the minis (not sure what that will be yet). Painting one of these dudes takes me about a week with the spare time I have and that suits me fine.

Anyway, stay safe with the coronavirus whatever your lockdown status and if you have any comments, I’d love to hear them!

Self isolation – it’s not to be sneezed at

Crikey, my office has been closed and we’re all to work from home ‘until further notice.’ People have been panic buying at the supermarkets. O and I have been panic buying in the toy shop and got a 5,000 piece jigsaw in case we have to go into total lock down.

I’ve also picked up some hobby stuff. I haven’t hobbied for a long time. You can find out why here but it’s not hobby related. Thanks, by the way, to the people who have read that separate post and especially anyone who got back to me. It means a lot.

Anyway, what that means is that despite having had this blog for nearly two years I’m kind of at a place where I’m starting again. I’ve got my 40k army (you can find all about that here), my 30K army (here), and my Necromunda gang (here). They’re all finished and ready to play. I also have quite a bit of grey plastic; half an AoS army (here) and half an AT army (here). I’ll bring those things to my new home soon but I don’t have anything to paint them with. My airbrush, my paints, my hobby tools, they’re all gone.

So what’s this post about? I guess this post is about testing how far my skills have degraded through not being used and also about making some small, tentative steps back into hobbying.

Where to start? With some models right? Ok cool. There’s a FLGS in my new town with actually quite a cool little GW section. I want something manageable. They stock Underworlds stuff. I’ve made a SCE gang for Underworlds before, it’s a good chance to practise NMM and get a whole new game system under my belt in one go. So I picked up these golden bois…

They look pretty cool, as I said I can practise my NMM on them as a way of seeing where my skills are at right now and it’s a small discrete force. In the box there’s quite a lot of value (in GW terms) for GBP20.

The cards are straight in the bin because I don’t speak Spanish (before anyone accuses me of being an ignorant cunt, they’d probably be straight in the bin if they were in English because I don’t play this game (or any other game at the moment)). The models are really nice. Step one, as always, is to give them a double dip bath in soapy water and a scrub with an old toothbrush. These were really shiny straight out of the box so I felt they really needed it.

I picked up some basic hobby bits so I could get these built and painted (I’ll do a separate post on the painting).

The clippers that GW makes now are legit. They cut really clean and they angled so they get really close too. I don’t think I’ve used any better ones. I used a little bit of the glue on these guys – it’s not great but it’s just glue. I make some Revell models with my kids and this is the sort of glue I use for that, it’s fine. I’ve got some liquid green stuff (out of shot), a box and cloths for a wet palette and some spray undercoat. The loser out of all this lot is the knife. It can fuck right off to be honest. It’s not a hobby knife, it’s the kind of knife you use to lay carpet. My FLGS does have the GW one in stock but it’s GBP20 and I had this one lying around. Next time I buy any models, I’ll buy the proper knife.

The kits are easy build which means they don’t need glue.(I only used glue on two parts) and actually go together nicely and look really cool. I think the easy build concept is slightly weird if I’m honest. The models still need clipping out, cleaning up and scraping – the glue is kind of the least difficult and dangerous part to be honest.

There’s just one problem I have with the easy build kits (I’ve only ever had easy build SCE so it may be unique to the golden bois) and that’s joins across the shoulder pads:

The shoulder pad is such a large, flat area that the join between the two pieces just stands out like dogs’ balls on a goldfish. Anyway, I’ve filled them with LGS and they’ve actually come out pretty good:

Noooice. Ok, three golden boys filled and scraped and ready to be undercoated. Once they’re undercoated, any mould lines show up much better so I do one layer of undercoat, scrape them back then a second layer of undercoat. I won’t bother photographing that, I’m bored just thinking about it let alone writing about it or you reading it. I’ll update when I’m ready to lay some paint down.

Any comments, let me know.

Starting. With an Ending.

Ok you’re probably here because I rank well for ‘Necromunda list building,’ and weren’t expecting this at all. Well, those links are at the top of the page. This post is about how nothing really matters except what really matters. And that’s not Necromunda list building.

This blog was always meant to be a bit of light relief from a pretty weird and hectic life. A way of charting my course from an enthusiastic nerd to a decent gamer and hopefully a way of documenting an improved set of painting skills. What could be simpler or more innocent?

So here I am 18 months later with…Everything that matters and at the same time, nothing that doesn’t (which means nothing relevant to this blog).

I wanted to have access to new game systems. Guess what? The armies I painted for two game systems (Kill Team and Nightvault) I don’t have any more and my other armies are in storage.

I wanted to become a better painter. Guess what? I now own no paints, no brushes and no hobby material.

I wanted to attend more gaming events with my mates en route to becoming a better gamer. Guess what? I now have no gaming mates.

What happened since my last blog post? Difficult one to come to terms with to be honest…I survived and escaped from an abusive relationship.

It’s hard to talk about because I’m a bloke. A grown up bloke. She was my partner. Superficially we had a good life; expensive cars, expensive stuff, nice apartments, living abroad.

But the fuel for the relationship was abuse and cruelty and humiliation;

Isolation from my family and my friends (including a campaign of defamation and lies which means I’ll never get back relationships built over years).

Financial abuse costing me, about £250,000 in lost assets and cash in the last four years. I’ve also subsequently had my flat burgled..

Physical abuse costing me my own teeth and some scars that Harry Potter would be proud of and…

Sexual abuse that I’m opening up about here so that I own it. I (a man) was abused sexually by my partner (a woman) for a period of four years. It’s hard to say, and before writing this now only three people (apart from the perpetrator) knew about it. It’s stuff I wouldn’t want anyone to know to be honest but now that some people do I feel better about being open about it than hiding it.

Fuck me, no one wants to read this right? So what happened?

One afternoon I had my face split open (again). I had my spectacles destroyed (again). I had lots of my possessions smashed (again). Finally my partner broke a mirror over the back of my head and told me she was going to kill me. I knew it was true.

So I grabbed my emergency bag (I had an emergency bag from about 4 months into our ‘relationship,’ which just became normalised after the tenth time I’d needed it) and walked out, never to see her again.

That was it. My job, my home, my stuff. I just upped and left. It was that or die. I knew it, she knew it.

Just think about that. I had a pair of trousers, three t-shirts and some underwear plus the clothes I stood in. Add in my passport and wallet and there, at 41 stood I. Fast forward almost a year and where am I now?

I’m working in a new job which I love, in a great country which I’m learning to love (it’s not in the UK but it’s English speaking – I’m not disclosing as I’m staying under the radar now).

I’m involved in a police investigation into the abuse I suffered which I hope will be concluded soon.

I’m rebuilding my relationship with my family and I’m reconciled to building new relationships with new people (probably through this hobby).

And, crucially, I’ve met a partner who is patient and kind and clever. I wasn’t looking for her and she wasn’t looking for me but it was right and home is now safe and nourishing and I’m happy. I’m happy. For the first time in years, I’m happy.

I’m not happy all the time. I still don’t sleep more than 4 hours a night. I still get very emotional. I still get angry for no reason. I’m still ashamed of myself. I still feel guilty. I still feel disgusting. I still feel like I deserved it. But I’m happy.

I survived. If you’re reading this and dealing with what I dealt with, you too can survive. I’m not here to tell you what to do but if you are dealing with what I dealt with, the likelihood is you don’t have anyone you can tell. So here’s my survival tip and I’m not trivialising matters; just walk out. When all else fails, just walk out. If you stay there, you’ll probably die. If you walk out you probably won’t. Play the odds; just walk out.

Then when you’re out, get help. Get police support, even if they’re useless then you’ll feel better for it. Get counselling support. Get all the support you can. Pick and choose the pace you recover at and who you turn to to help your recovery.

The fact is being abused makes you stronger, not weaker. It makes you stronger because it makes you realise that good health and being able to sleep without being scared of not waking up is worth more than your diamond cufflinks. or your Mercedes Benz. Or your expensive clarinet. Or your clothes. Or the photos of your kids. Or…It makes you stronger because a true position of strength is when you have nothing left to lose except life itself. It may feel like you have nothing to gain either but nobody gained anything by being murdered by an abusive partner.

Defining my Beastclaw Raiders aesthetic part 3; the banners

This is the last final of my aesthetic ruminations. I now know that my beasts will be white (see here for why) and my ogres themselves will be darker skinned with some crazy trousers (see here for why). There’s just one more element I need to think through; freehand banners.

I should mention right up front that I’m a bit nervous about these. I haven’t actually picked up a paintbrush for a few months so I’m worried my skills have deteriorated (I don’t even have all my stuff to paint with) so I’ll probably keep these quite simple.

I’ve got three banners to paint: one each on the mournfang units and one I’m making to go on the Frostlord’s ‘throne,’ thingy.

The first decision I have to make is whether to stick with the GW ip or go my own way. The GW ip is very tribal, focusing on the lore around ‘the maw,’ (and there’s nothing wrong with that) and very easy to do (which fits with my worries nicely):

I could do this pretty easily (I think). But, after consultation with my doubles partner, we think more detailed freehand would be better to grab an army nomination.

Now, I’m not entirely without experience in freehand and I’m getting better at it too:

This is the way I want to go. My basic freehand skill set is limited to:

Skulls (thanks Richard Gray)
Climbing vines and flowers
Feathers

Now, if I don’t ever try anything else, I’ll never get any new skills. I’m fully on board with that so I’m going to look at doing all of the above and adding something else in too.

Fortuitously, an item I’m using in my army list to make my general -1 to hit is a feather. So, it makes sense to use my feather skills to paint that freehand on his banner. But what about the rest?

Each Mournfang banner has two sides (duh) and I like the theme I had for the skulls on the competition piece in the pics above. I’m thinking one blue banner with a skull and flowers on one side and the other unit with a red banner with a skull and chains on one side.

But what about the back of each banner? Hmm, I don’t know. One of the things I’m doing on the rest of the models is TMM but i do like the look of NMM. Maybe something I could do with that. The chains around one of the skulls will be NMM but is that enough?

In the Warhammer lore there are few things that go better with skulls than weapons. Weapons made of metal give a great opportunity for NMM. Let me do a quick internet search and have a look…

This. This can’t be hard to reproduce (this wasn’t the first one I came up with by the way, I did have a pretty thorough scan. I’m happy with these on the back of one banner with flowers on them and on the back of the other with chains around them.

See – wasn’t so hard after all. Now all I’ve got to do is actually paint them!

Defining my Beastclaw Raiders aesthetic part 2; The Ogors

I’m already nervous that this is going to stray into weird / potentially offensive territory. If it does, I apologise, I’m not malicious; I’m ignorant and stupid (which isn’t better than malicious it’s just harder to fix).

I went through a process to decide what colour the beasts in my BCR army would be (you can find that here, spoiler alert they’ll be polar bear coloured).

Now I want to do the same thing to define what colour my orges will be. Yeah, I know. I told you this could go one of two ways. Now, to be fair, it was a friend of mine who played ogres in 8th ed that put me onto this. In the 8th ed fluff the Ogres are a mountain dwelling, nomadic race that look like this:

Credit Games Workshop.

Pretty cool huh. I think so too. Only mountain dwelling, nomadic people don’t actually look like that. Especially from the polar regions. They kind of look more like this:

Firstly, I’m in love. Secondly, this lady is from Greenland. The thing I’m trying to point out is that gorgeous skin tone. I also think her clothes are fucking cool – more on that later actually. Her skin tone isn’t at all like the GW ip. Here are some more examples (from Nepal this time):

Credit (left to right): https://www.andbeyond.com/tailormade-tours/nepalese-mountain-tour-jungle-safari/ and https://www.pinterest.com/subenjabegu/people-in-nepal/

So I’m going to go out on a limb here and use this darker skin tone for my ogres. I think it will pop nicely against the white of the beasts. It will also, I’ve just realised, give me a a nice contrast with the clothes.

Looking at the GW ip again you can see that all ogres wear boring trousers. Actually, the trouser areas on the ogres are quite big and they’re also quite segmented (there’s a seam running right over the lap cutting the pants in two basically). I think these are a great opportunity for freehand. Those of you who have suffered through my AT aesthetic which is here (whatever happened to them eh? Actually, I’ll be back on those as soon as this tournament is over) will know I have a thing for acrobats. And travelling circuses. And cool clothes. So I was thinking of doing some kind of mad stripes and patterns on the ogres clothes. Something like this:

Credit (L to R) https://www.halloweencostumes.com/

But I’m not so sure now. The clothes that the lady from Greenland and the people from Nepal are wearing is also very cool. I think I’ll amalgamate the two and use the basic patterns from the clown clothes but use the super cool colours from the reference material.

As always, if you have any comments, let me know. The next stage will be picking 3 freehand designs (with some variation) for the banners.

As always, any comments – hit me up

Choosing my Beastclaw Raiders aesthetic part 1 – the beasts

I’ve written something like this section for just about every army I’ve built recently. Before I put paint on my Beastclaw Raiders army (you can read more about them here) I want to be very clear about the aesthetic and what I’m trying to achieve. As I type this I have no more than a very cursory idea of what that is, so here’s hoping putting words down helps!

I’m going to start with the beasts themselves and then when I’ve got that sorted I’ll move on to the ogres (ogors?) and finally the freehand elements. It all has to work together though so that will be considered at the end too.

Starting from the bottom up

I have an award winning painter doing my bases for me (a wise man, I don’t remember who or where once wrote that great miniature painting is about faces and bases) so these need to be factored in. They’re snow bases with grey rock on. So it makes sense that my Beastclaw Raiders come from somewhere cold. So what does that mean for the colours of my beasts?

How cold is cold?

Ok so let’s start from the top. Or the bottom. But let’s start somewhere polar. To be clear, this is a miniature gaming blog, not a copy of National Geographic so what I’m looking for here is reference material. A quick search of the internet for ‘Polar animals,’ brings up the usual suspects:

(credit clockwise from left: https://animalhow.com/arctic-animals-north-pole/ , https://www.steppestravel.com/en-us/arctic-big-5/ , https://www.coolantarctica.com/Antarctica%20fact%20file/arctic_animal.php)

I do like this look and I think it would be good to paint and stand out. It’s not white (I don’t think there’s a single white strand of hair on any of these animals) so the colour differences would be great to paint. Being light coloured would also make any free hand pop even more.

What does GW think?

One thing I am wondering is if deviating from the ip in terms of colours etc would damage our chances of an army nomination. Well, actually, light coloured big beasts are a thing:

Credit: https://www.games-workshop.com/en-GB/beastclaw-raiders-frostlord-on-thundertusk

I don’t like the blue / grey ice shades they use as a base but I’m liking this light colour scheme even more now.

But Thundertusks and Stonehorns aren’t polar bears – they’re Mammoths?

Yeah, agreed and this is something else I’ve had buzzing around my head. Ogors are, effectively, cavemen. Their art and aesthetic is very caveman so it stands to reason that the things they’re riding are tame mammoths (reason?) So what colour were they?

Credit from left to right: https://www.sciencenews.org/article/resurrecting-woolly-mammoth-cells-dna , http://www.fossilmall.com/EDCOPE_Enterprises/vertebrates/vfossil25/vertfossils25.htm

Sorry for the pretty gross pic. Basically they were ginger. For some reason this was the original colour I had in my head for how to paint the big beasts (I think this was just because that’s how my mate who played Ogres in 8th had them). The problem with this colour is that it’s going to make it very hard for freehand and other colours to pop against it. A lighter colour (like the creamy off white with grey patches on the wolf above) is visually interesting but also works as a canvas.

Ok, I’m glad I wrote this – polar Beastclaws it is! As always, any comments or queries let me know!

Some progress on the Ogres!

So it’s been a couple of weeks since the last update and I’m less stressed entirely because I should be more stressed about Beastclaw Raiders army building but cannot do anything to change where my hobby is at. Still following? Cool…

As you may have read (here) I’m playing at an AoS doubles event in October and I’m taking Beastclaw Raiders (1,000 points of them in 6 models). My doubles partner is doing the bases so they all look consistent (he doesn’t know it yet but he’ll be doing another 1,000 points of bases for me after the event so I can scale up). Well, good news – the models are built.

Putting them together

Actually, before we get to that, just a quick note on buying the army. One of the things that I really liked about this army was that it was a Start Collecting! box and a separate large model kit. Full retail was ~93 pounds but from an independent that I know of offering 15% off this was to become 79 pounds. Great value for 1,000 points and potentially 158 quid for a 2,000 point army.

Only no one has the models. The indie had the SC! box but no separate monster, GW in Nottingham (at WHW) had the monster and no SC! box and I needed them all quickly. I was only in the UK for a few days. Part of the complication of this project is that I’m also moving internationally (again) and starting a new job (again) and won’t have any of my building or painting stuff.

Ultimately what I did was panic and bought two SC! boxes from a local GW store at full retail so paid 110 pounds for something that could have cost me 79 or should have cost, at most, 93. At least I have all the battle line for the second 1,000 points sorted.

Actually putting them together

Right, weird money rant over, how did the models go together? Really well actually. I scraped and filed everything and glued it together (no bases yet) and I’ve fabricated a banner for the FrostLord on Thundertusk from aluminium can (I’ll do a little walkthrough on that when I come to paint them). The big job was gap filling. My doubles partner has got some history of success with painting at WHW. He’s won a Best Army at a 30K ToS (30K has the highest hobby standard in my opinion (obviously this is my blog so this is all my opinion) and was nominated for Best Army at the last 30K doubles event up there.

He’s keen that we get our army looking as good as we can and we push for a nomination here too. So gap filling and prep are really important to that – nothing says ‘tabletop standard,’ quite like gaps in joints and mould lines. The gaps in the orges, especially on the backs of their necks and around their shoulder blades where the arms join the body are huge. They took four layers of liquid green stuff and sanding to correct.

The next step is to spray prime these with a grey to really show up any mould lines and other imperfections I’ve missed (once the plastic has been stressed through being cut or sanded or bent then it goes different colours and makes seeing these things hard).

So when?

Great question. The Beastclaw Raiders army building should resume sometime around the start of September. My plan is to buy all the painting stuff I need around then and have it shipped to a UK address. Then I fly back to make sure it’s all in order and while I’m there I finish the Beastclaw Raiders army building and get them absolutely ready to start painting. Painting won’t actually begin that weekend (no time) but I’m planning to fly back to the UK for the full week before the event to paint everything in a week. I think that will make a great series of blog posts and I hope you enjoy them!

What’s next?

Before I fly back to make sure the painting stuff is all together and progress the build itself I want to take some time to decide on the aesthetic for my army. That will be next Sunday, until then – any comments, let me know!

Writing my AoS list

Back when AoS first dropped I was all over it. Everything was exploitable, nobody really knew what anybody else’s army did (or what their own did usually) and the whole thing was carnage.

Back then I went 5-0 at a ToS at Warhammer World by exploiting terrain rules (I invented Balewind Vortex spam) to help me generate really overwhelming first turn force. (Back when the game first dropped, everyone was obsessed with going second to get the double turn. I made sure my lists were best going first because it doesn’t matter if you get the double turn when your army has already evaporated).

That was then, this is now

But fast forward a few years and everything has changed. I haven’t played the game for years. The game has exploded in popularity, there’s a matched play points system and a very hectic release schedule. It’s a completely different game in short. Completely different AND completely alien to me. So this list writing piece isn’t the place to come if you want a net list from a Masters winner. I’m going to lay out my principles of list building, show how it relates to the list I write and identify the strengths and weaknesses.

What’s the list for?

Great question. This is a 1,000 point Beast Claw Raiders list (you can find the thought process around BCR here) that will be half of a doubles list. My doubles partner is taking Khorne (not very fluffy, this is just a good excuse for us all to get together). After the event I’ll write a second part of this piece where I expand this 1,000 points to a full 2,000 point list (once I have more chance to see the army and the scenarios in action).

List building principles

My thoughts on list building are fairly consistent across game systems and are basically:

  1. Be active in as many phases as possible. Just giving up entire phases isn’t usually a route to success. Even Dwarves in WHFB had runic abilities in lieu of magic, for example.
  2. Be very good in at least one phase. Armies that do a bit of everything without being any good at anything are also problematic because they don’t force an opponent to make any hard decisions. If an army is very good at something, then an opponent will need to factor mitigating that at the expense of executing their own plans
  3. Build to compete in all scenarios (don’t have any ‘auto lose,’ scenarios). This is an absolute given to me but I’m surprised by how many players don’t really care. The number of times I’d play WHFB 8th at a tournament, roll the banners mission and my opponent would say ‘Oh, I’ve only got two banners in my army’. The scenarios are the game for me – the game isn’t ‘kill everything you can’
  4. Mine the books for synergy and hidden gems. This is the fun and, from what I’ve read, this is where AoS is really deep – lots of synergy, lots of hidden depth to lists.
  5. Don’t play the meta, play what beats the meta. I still think this is great advice and BCR definitely aren’t recognized as top tier but this falls down when you don’t know what the meta is. I’ve read and heard about FEC, DoK and Skaven but not sure how to build to beat these as I don’t know all their tricks. This will likely be more for the 2,000 point list.

Writing a BeastClaw Raiders list

Having got this far, I feel like I should own up to something here – the BCR book doesn’t have very many choices in it (and most of them are characters) so there’s not much finesse to picking something and not much flexibility when trying to write to the rules above. In fact, this is going to be a compromise of points / availability vs the rules above.

1,000 points and the army structure

This list is a Vanguard (1,000 points list). The limitations are:

  • 1-4 leaders
  • Minimum of two battle line units
  • Maximum of two behemoths
  • Maximum of two artillery pieces
  • Up to 200 points of allies

The leader

One of the reasons I picked BCR was the big monster models and so my general will definitely be one of these. The big monster models take up a leader AND a behemoth slot so in this list will be one of a maximum of two of the big kits. The big decision here is Stonehorn or Thundertusk.

Stonehorns are cheaper and in a list where I need all the points I can get, this is important and they’re great in combat (they do impact hits, and they half the damage from multi damage weapons) but for a general they’re not for me for one reason: Frenzy. These models have to attempt a charge if they are with 12″ and, as per the FAQ, if the charge roll would get them in they have to make it. Now, it’s a combat model so that’s not a problem right? Well, I agree for battleline units but I want more flexibility over where I put my general. I want to make the positive choice to charge my general rather than having to. So, even if they weren’t awesome (which they are) it’s a general on Thundertusk for me.

But which general? Huskard or Frostlord. Easy; I think BCR should be led my the most powerful model available – Frostlord it is. This model is more survivable (an extra wound and a better save) which is important and although I think the Huskard command ability is very good, I think the Frostlord one (reroll charges) is good enough.

The battleline

Having spent 420 points on a leader, I’ve got 580 points left and I have to spend some on Battleline to make the list legal.

Now, here’s where the rules for list building can be referenced. On paper, my view is that Grots are the best battleline for BCR. You can take massive units of them to objective camp and work as board control where as the other choices (Mournfang / Beastriders) are either single units or very small. However, I don’t have long to put this army together and building / painting hundreds of grots isn’t for me. So, if you’re reading this, take grots. I’m taking mournfang because, fortuitously, the ‘Start collecting BCR’ box has a Frostlord on Thundertusk and four mournfang in it. That’s my leader and battleline sorted!

The rest

Ok so with five models I’ve covered my compulsory elements (a leader and two battleline units). I’ve also got 300 points left over. Now, again, looking back at my list writing rules, the smart play here is to ally in a wizard for less than 200 points (a Firebelly) and then spend 180 points on bodies to contest objectives (some yhetees / frost sabres). So if you’re reading this, do that. I haven’t – I’m putting in another big monster (Stonehorn Beastriders to be precise) as it fits the points exactly and it’s fewer models to prepare.

So that’s broadly the list

One Frostlord on Thundertusk
One Stonehorn Beastrider
Two units of two Mournfang

Six models. I should be able to get this built and painted in time. But how does it match up against my rules?

Rules are meant to be broken

Be active in every phase. This list has powerful command abilities, is fast in the movement phase and charge phase, shoots (albeit short range) and is combat focused. So that’s all great. It does, however, miss an entire phase (magic) which is a really important one in this game. Am I worried? Yes. My doubles partner has no magic either. Is there anything I can do to mitigate it? Kind of, there is a magic item which grants a dispel which is good. But there are lots of good items, I may just have to suck the lack of magic up.
Be really good at something. Fighting. Next.
Compete in all scenarios. This is a real weakness here. There aren’t enough bodies to contest any objectives, so I’m going to have to kill everything. A better list (and possibly my 2K list) will include grots / more bodies.
Mine the books. Having done this, there’s a great item in the realm of beasts called the feather. This makes all attacks -1 to hit against the bearer. So I put that on my general and he’s -1 against shooting and -2 against combat. Sweet.
Beat the meta. We’ll just have to see I guess

So, ultimately, this post has been more of a ‘how not to do it,’ than a lesson in list writing. Don’t be me!

Comments always welcome.

Picking my AoS army

So you may have read that I’m attending an AoS event in October (81 days away from today to be precise).  I don’t have an army to take so I need to pick one quickly.  Here are my criteria:

  1. I’ve got to love the models.  This comes first over everything.  I’m only really in this hobby for the building and painting – the tournaments are just an excuse for a good time with my mates.
  2. It needs to be low model count.  I don’t have long and I still want the army to look good(ish) so low model count is definitely a thing
  3. I want it to be aggressive.  My 40K army (you can read about that here) is quite fast and shooty and tricky (it’s Eldar, it’s just how they roll).  I’d like something a bit more, umh, straightforward for AoS.
  4. I don’t want lots of metal panels, I’d like the army to be organic.  This is because I’ve just painted lots of metal (you can see some of that here) and I want to do something different.

So I’ve been through a quick check of the armies on the GW website and scored them against this list as follows:

Grand alliance Order

Criteria Aelves DoK Dwarves Empire Fyreslayers
Models Y N Y Y N
Elite Y N N N Y
Fighty N Y Y N Y
Skin N Y N Y Y
Criteria DK KO Lizards SCE Sylvaneth
Models Y Y N Y N
Elite Y Y N Y N
Fighty N Y Y Y Y
Skin Y N Y N Y

Grand Alliance Chaos

BOC BOK DoT EC HoS Nurgle Skaven
Models Y N Y N Y N N
Elite N N N Y Y N N
Fighty Y Y N Y N Y N
Skin Y Y Y N Y Y Y

Grand Alliance Death

Criteria / army FEC LoN NH
Love the models Y Y Y
Low model count N Y N
Aggressive Y N N
Organic aesthetic Y N N

Grand Alliance Destruction

Criteria / army BCR BS GSG GB IJ
Love the models Y N N Y Y
Low model count Y N N Y N
Aggressive Y Y N Y Y
Organic aesthetic Y Y Y Y N

So my slightly shorter long list is:

Order Chaos Death Destruction
Deepkin BoC FEC BCR
KO HoS   GB
SCE      

Right, let’s start whittling these down.  A few of these I’ve had armies for before (in WHFB 8th) and so I feel like I’d be missing a chance to do something new if I went back to them. So for that reason out go:

  • BoC (even though these are my true gaming love and I will do an army in the future)
  • FEC (painting ghouls can, 100%, FEC off)

The nest step is carriage.  I travel internationally and might do so with the army so, actually, I want something fairly robust that I don’t worry about snapping.  That means goodbye to:

  • Deepkin
  • KO
  • HoS (another shame because I think these are really tasty)

So I’m down to three.  Stormcast, BeastClaw Raiders and GutBusters.  I’ve had a SCE army in AoS before (I painted it horribly) and whilst I could do a great job now there’s not the organic aesthetic I’m looking for.  So now we’re down to two.  Both BCR and GB are great looking armies.  I loved them in 8th ed (my best mate played them competitively so I never collected them).  I now have the opportunity to run an army with a very, very low model count.  Not sure how they’ll stand up to international travel but hello to my new AoS army…BeastClaw Raiders!